Forum | Why are the Chinese in region B?

Why are the Chinese in region B?

By danelybella - 02-05-2023 02:13

[Fzmex]

They have a very active market and are always bidding for all the players just to buy and sell, I think they should be in region A, and not be allowed to have so many foreigners.

Re: Why are the Chinese in region B?

By darkline - 03-05-2023 00:29

[FLUSA]
President

I've been complaining about that for years but no one listens.... is not just China, also Romania, doesn't make sense that this Countries with very large markets share the same region as Mexico or USA that sometimes don't even have more than 10 players on the market.

I suppose the answer to the question is because no one can be bothered to solve the problem.

Re: Why are the Chinese in region B?

By spencer2229 - 27-05-2023 09:49

[Perros]

The only way to make it fair would be to scrap the foreign player limit all together,

I imagine they haven't implemented it because it would be difficult to remove the excess foreign players from the teams in China, Romania etc

I did write my opinion on the argument and counter argument but deleted it as it was to long winded

Re: Why are the Chinese in region B?

By chucky06 - 01-06-2023 10:20

[AUSNZ]
President

+1 the game is designed to favour the biggest countries and it always has since when everything swayed to favour Swedish teams

Re: Why are the Chinese in region B?

By darkline - 01-06-2023 12:53

[FLUSA]
President

Nop that's not the reason, it was supposed to be adjusted every year but it was only adjusted the 1st year after much insistance and because the imbalance was even worst than it is now.

Removing the excess foreign players is no problem because you don't remove them, you just apply the new limit to the Country meaning that you keep the foreign players you already have but if you're overlimit, when you sell a foreign player you won't be able to replace him with a new foreign player.

For comparison, USA & China are on the same Region, we have at the moment 12 USA players on the market, Australia has 11 players, China has 237 players.... then a Region C Country like Canada has at the moment 18 players, Scotland 15 players.

Is not only us, for example Portugal is on Region A with all the big guys like Argentina/Brazil/etc. and they have 85 players on the market, less than half as China and obviously a lot less than Argentina

It's obvious USA/Australia & a few more belong to Region C but the reason they don't do anything to resolve this situation is because they don't care about us, there's no excuse as this is the simplest thing in the world to fix, truth is our userbase is small and our worth isn't enough for them to expend one hour of hard work to make a simple change like revising the Regions.

If this is something that affected Argentina/Brazil/China etc. and their users complained and made noise, this would have been sorted out ages ago. Maybe we need to get the Portuguese onboard to complain and make noise as it seems they don't realize how dissadvantaged they're by being on Region A with all the big boys (Sweden/Argentina/Poland/Turkey/Brazil are the other Countries that make Region A)

spencer2229 wrote:

I imagine they haven't implemented it because it would be difficult to remove the excess foreign players from the teams in China, Romania etc

Nop that's not the reason, it was supposed to be adjusted every year but it was only adjusted the 1st year after much insistance and because the imbalance was even worst than it is now.

Removing the excess foreign players is no problem because you don't remove them, you just apply the new limit to the Country meaning that you keep the foreign players you already have but if you're overlimit, when you sell a foreign player you won't be able to replace him with a new foreign player.

For comparison, USA & China are on the same Region, we have at the moment 12 USA players on the market, Australia has 11 players, China has 237 players.... then a Region C Country like Canada has at the moment 18 players, Scotland 15 players.

Is not only us, for example Portugal is on Region A with all the big guys like Argentina/Brazil/etc. and they have 85 players on the market, less than half as China and obviously a lot less than Argentina

It's obvious USA/Australia & a few more belong to Region C but the reason they don't do anything to resolve this situation is because they don't care about us, there's no excuse as this is the simplest thing in the world to fix, truth is our userbase is small and our worth isn't enough for them to expend one hour of hard work to make a simple change like revising the Regions.

If this is something that affected Argentina/Brazil/China etc. and their users complained and made noise, this would have been sorted out ages ago. Maybe we need to get the Portuguese onboard to complain and make noise as it seems they don't realize how dissadvantaged they're by being on Region A with all the big boys (Sweden/Argentina/Poland/Turkey/Brazil are the other Countries that make Region A)